Wall.fm Blog · building communities ✦

Growth and spam

Invite-only community: closing the door can make the room better.

Open, free site registration grows fast and attracts spam just as fast. An invite only community trades some growth for members who arrive with a connection to someone already inside.

Here is when that trade is worth it and how to run invites fairly.

When an invite only community makes sense

Signs it is time.

  • Spam accounts outnumber genuine sign-ups.
  • Moderators spend more time removing accounts than helping members.
  • The community’s value depends on trust, such as a professional or support group.

Well-known examples include Gmail’s invite-only launch in 2004 and the long invite-only periods of sites such as Dribbble, where invitations also signalled quality.

How invite systems work

Three common models.

Models
ModelHow it works
Member inviteseach member gets a few invitations
Applicationnewcomers answer two or three questions
Waiting listopen sign-up, admitted in batches

Keeping it fair

Avoid becoming a clique.

  1. Publish how to get in. A clear route beats “know someone”.
  2. Track who invites whom. Invite trees help find spam rings.
  3. Review the policy regularly. Reopen free registration when spam drops.

Sources and further reading

Where the facts on this page come from.

External reference · dribbble.com

Dribbble ↗

Design community with a history of invitations.